UPDATE (2/10/14): Following the Feb 8 update to this piece, we’ve now published an apology to Flappy Bird‘s creator and a full accounting of what I believe was going on with reaction to
y1 com games the game. Please find that here. -Stephen Totilo, Editor-in-Chief, Kotaku.com(new Image()).src = 'https://capi.connatix.com/tr/si?token=995c4c7d-194f-4077-b0a0-7ad466eb737c&cid=872d12ce-453b-4870-845f-955919887e1b'; cnx.cmd.push(function() { cnx({ playerId: "995c4c7d-194f-4077-b0a0-7ad466eb737c" }).render("79703296e5134c75a2db6e1b64762017"); }); https://kotaku.com/the-flappy-bird-fiasco-1519938266 UPDATE (2/8/14): This article was originally titled “Flappy Bird Is Making $50,000 A Day Off Ripped Art.” Given that the word “ripped” can be interpreted as “lifted,” I’ve decided to change the headline for the sake of clarity. Before scrutinizing the
two pipes side by side, I believed that Flappy Bird‘s art was directly taken from Mario—however, when examined, it’s clear that Flappy Bird‘s pipe is a new albeit unoriginal drawing. The similarities are apparent, as I originally noted, but “ripped” may have been too harsh a word.
Original article follows: Everybody’s talking about Flappy Bird. We’ve all kind of just accepted it as a mobile phenomenon—the type of “little guy strikes big” story that has endeared millions to the likes of Notch (Minecraft) and Dean Hall (DayZ). In fact, Flappy Bird has gotten so big that its creator, Dong Nguyen, told The Verge he’s making $50,000 a day on ad revenue. $50,000 a day! That’s $18 million
a year, FYI.
Naturally, the Flappy Bird sensation has garnered a wide range of reactions from critics and pundits. Most people acknowledge that it’s a terrible game—which it is—and many have attempted to dissect its massive appeal. (Ian Bogost’s analysis at The Atlantic is the most compelling I’ve read so far.)
But people seem to be glossing over one important fact: nothing in Flappy Bird is original. The Verge points out that much of the art is “inspired” by Super Mario Bros., but this game goes beyond inspiration. We’re in ripoff territory here. https://kotaku.com/the-most-popular-app-on-itunes-is-an-impossible-ad-rid-1508171485 Look at the pipes, for example: On the left is Flappy Bird; on the right is Super Mario World.
Weird to think that some kids might grow up thinking these are “Flappy Bird pipes.” Even the twinkly sound effect when your bird flies between pipes is heavily inspired by Mario’s coin-collecting chime, to the point where they sound nearly identical.
And what about the bird itself? While the eponymous Flappy Bird isn’t a direct ripoff, it appears to be a cross between the Spike and Cheep Cheep enemies in Super Mario Bros. 3. See if you can spot the similarities: (Left: Flappy Bird. Right/Top: Spike. Right/Bottom: Cheep-Cheep.) The backgrounds also appear to be heavily inspired by Mario, perhaps as a subtle protest against Nintendo for not bringing their biggest games to iOS, or perhaps because Nguyen made
Y1 COM the game in three days. (We’ve reached out to Nguyen for comment, and will update should he respond.) Let this be a life lesson: if you want to make $50,000 a day, put ripped art in a terrible game.
UPDATE, 2/8: The game’s creator says he now
Y1 Games wants to remove Flappy Bird due to some of the reaction the game has received. When asked if it was because of criticism of the game’s art, he said it was not and also said it was not due to any legal issues. @misterlukeherb @kotaku Ah, I didn't directly stole something. It is quite an art to doing that 🙂 — Dong Nguyen (@dongatory) February 8, 2014